The seal of the Supreme Court of South Carolina. (File/FOX Carolina)
GREENVILLE, SC (FOX Carolina) -
It's a tradition that, whether they admit it or not, many people take part in - a game of poker inside of a home.
"There are hundreds of games of Texas Hold 'Em poker being played as a hobby by individuals having a friendly or casual game every night in South Carolina," said lawyer Billy Wilkins.
But one game back in 2006 in Mount Pleasant went too far. It resulted in arrests and a long legal battle that ended Wednesday in a South Carolina Supreme Court decision.
The issue isn't with the games themselves but the money being made and who is making the money.
Wilkins represented the defendants in the case and gave an example where it's illegal.
"If you turn it into a commercial activity - for example, if I were to charge admission to come in and play Texas Hold 'Em poker - that would be used as a house used as a place of gaming," Wilkins said.
Authorities used a law that's been on the state books since 1802, which set out guidelines on gambling. Wilkins said those laws are now outdated and deserve another look.
State Sen. Larry Martin, a Republican from Pickens County, is on the Senate Judiciary Committee and agrees with the decision.
But Martin said he's fearful of what could happen in the future.
"Another case could be brought (in) and bring down the entire statute because of the 3-2 decision and the way they ruled," said Martin.
The ruling, in the most basic terms, allows games of poker to be played in a person's home, as long as the house doesn't charge a cover or take a cut. If there is a profit made on the part of the house, it's considered a house of gambling, and considered illegal.
The dissenting opinion in the case said that the 210-year-old law was and is too vague and could be unconstitutional.
"The ball is in the lap of the legislature," said Wilkins.
Martin said he wants to fix that, but also said the process will take some time and a lot of work.
"Anytime we address gambling statutes, if we aren't very careful, we can create another problem that we didn't anticipate or another loophole that permits gaming or gambling," Martin said.
Copyright 2012 FOX Carolina (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.
Saturday, May 18 2013 8:31 PM EDT2013-05-19 00:31:53 GMT
Anderson county deputies said a woman was rescued as she fought to stay afloat in the Saluda River on Saturday.Deputies were called out near Osteen Hill Road around 3:30 p.m. after a woman tried to crossMore >
Anderson County deputies said a woman was rescued as she fought to stay afloat in the Saluda River on Saturday.More >
Saturday, May 18 2013 8:30 PM EDT2013-05-19 00:30:43 GMT
Anderson police said a man was shot in the back Saturday night.Police said the victim got in his car and tried to chase down the person who shot him on Burdine Street around 6:30 p.m.Police say the victimMore >
Anderson police said a man was shot in the back Saturday night.More >
Friday, May 17 2013 11:20 PM EDT2013-05-18 03:20:45 GMT
An Upstate woman's money is gone and her friend got hit too. They don't know when their debit card numbers got swiped, but they think there may be more victims in the area. After a frustrating few days,More >
An Upstate woman and her friend have both lost money from their banking accounts - money they did not spend themselves.More >
Friday, May 17 2013 3:01 PM EDT2013-05-17 19:01:38 GMT
Video of State Representative Ted Vick chronicles the Pee Dee lawmaker's interaction with Bureau of Protective Services officers late Tuesday night as he was arrested for DUI in the State House parkingMore >
Video of Democratic State Representative Ted Vick chronicles the Pee Dee lawmaker's interaction with Bureau of Protective Services officers late Tuesday night as he was arrested for DUI in the State House parking garage.More >
A poll by Reader's Digest named the 100 most trusted people in America. The list includes celebrities, politicians, philanthropists and even presidents. Click here to see the top 30.More >
A poll by Reader's Digest named the 100 most trusted people in America. The list includes celebrities, politicians, philanthropists and even presidents, and Readers Digest admits the results were surprising. Click here to see the top 30. More >